Appointment Trader
Search 
Sign In
Developers
How It Works
Get into Old Homestead Steak House Atlantic City! 🔥
Chat
Buyer Protection
Option to Cancel
Alias Check-In
Upload Your Reservation Now
10 users watching
Old Homestead Steak House Atlantic City Reviews
The service and staff are attentive and professional.
Porterhouse was very good. Bacon side was good, as were the clams. Is the best? No. But a good experience.
My husband keep telling me about the restaurant.
How was his steak warm even on the middle of the steak. There is still Smoke coming out from the steak still when he was on the half of it. Yesterday We've been. İ like the ambience and the experiences service. I like soup and salad. Top of
This isn’t fine dining - more like a bar that serves steaks.
We were booted and suited and had a reservation two weeks in advance. Spent nearly $1,000 dollars. Arrived 45 minutes early and I TOLD the hostess we were here for formal dining in the dining room. This keel off seated us in the bar area. No whit
Failure by the staff led to disapointment
The food was really good what was disappointing was the failure of the establishment to control other customers with their unruly children.. it made the whole experience from a 10 to a 5.
Very nice special evening The ambience is wonderful The
Very nice special evening The ambience is wonderful The food is excellent The price is however, are like a mortgage payment You'll get a fine meal here and you won't be disappointed
The food was top notch and so was the service.
We didn't have reservations but they were able to fit us in and it was a wonderful experience. We will be back next time we're in the area. The atmosphere is very welcoming and comfortable.
The food is great and that's what keeps us coming back.
The service is usually too fast meaning we feel rushed every time. Slow it down waiters! I can spend that kind of money anywhere, and you are all so good, but the minute my fork went down, the next thing came out. A little too rushed for experienced
Decadent but disorganized
This is a decent decadent steak house. We did the 2 person porterhouse and it was quite good. The wedge salad was huge abs great to share The $14 asparagus was a rip off - literally 8 spears - cmon now! Biggest complaint was the hosting. We were f
We split the rack of lamb that was cooked to perfection.
Our waiter Michael was so professional and helpful. The atmosphere was very nice The restaurant was very busy which made it more enjoyable. Would definitely go back again.
4 of us had dinner at your steak house the other evening
4 of us had dinner at your steak house the other evening as we have done for years - although the prices are outrageous , we don't mind paying as long as the food quality, drinks and service are there - what was terribly upsetting to us was ,
Not disappointed at all
We had one of our lovely dinner at The Old Homestead Steak house. Very friendly service, the food was very good as well as presentation. One of the best onion soup we have ever tried. The prime Rib was cook to perfect. Very Tender and juicy. We will
Great ambiance and service Delicious steak and seafood.
Will dine there when in town
Go here for a very expensive good quality meal and taste of
Go here for a very expensive good quality meal and taste of nyc in nj! The manager was very gracious to seat us even tho we were late for our reservation because the parkway on a summer Friday is brutal with traffic. Thank god bc we were hangry and d
orrible experience this 4th of July weekend.
My family and I have dined at this restaurant many times. This past weekend I found a broken piece of glass in my drink which cut my tongue. It was a minor cut however the waiter as well as the manager were nonchalant about the situation. The glass w
This was our second visit to Old Homestead, and
This was our second visit to Old Homestead, and unfortunately, it was disappointing. We mentioned to both the busboy and one of the waiters that my boyfriend's steak was dry and overcooked--it was served medium instead of the medium rare he had
Great steaks, seafood, pasta, you name it, it's great.
Amazing service and atmosphere. Old Homestead - Atlantic City - Celebrating my youngest 21st birthday with a great dinner and gambling! Perfectly cooked steak, great salad, and she loved her pasta. Awesome cookie dessert. Wonderful wait staff made th
Not as good as in past trips
Have been coming to The Old Homestead at the Borgata once or twice a year for a long time. This time it felt like a step below other visits. We had a reservation, but had to wait a bit to be seated and were led at first to the table right next to t
It was ok
Service was very good, no real complaints there. Ever in search of the perfect burger, that is what we each ordered. It was huge. The onion rings were good. However, my well done burger did have a fair amount of pink on one half of it. Not what you
Consistent excellence
Kurt and Baldo were AMAZING servers this evening! Old Homestead is our favorite steakhouse in Atlantic City, but these gents went above and beyond and this time extra special! Keep up the excellent job guys!!! See ya soon!!
Steakhouse Perfection
We were visiting Atlantic City for my wife’s birthday and also celebrating my Daughter and new Son in law visiting from Korea. The food was excellent and the service was impeccable and we ate there 2 nights in a row. Yes you are going to spend a li
Top notch
We ate here twice this trip. Both nights were perfect, in fact none of the restaurants at Borgata match up to this, the food was perfect, the wine list excellent, ambience is great, and classy, the wait staff is terrific we especially liked Saul!!
dinner date
Overpriced, marginal quality steaks. I would compare to Texas Roadhouse quality. the hand cut fries were OK but not hot. I'm thinking our order sat for a few minutes before served, steak was not hot either, barely warm. Lot's of other c
It was recently renovated so everything inside is clean and
It was recently renovated so everything inside is clean and fairly new. The service is fantastic, even though a few guys have a bit of Jersey attitude, and while they occasionally sound snarky they are always on point. You never wait for a thing. T
Great food, atmosphere and hospitality .
Everything is amazing . Will def be back. Highly recommend the lobster mac and cheese and brussel sprouts
The food and service is amazing every single time we eat
The food and service is amazing every single time we eat here. Ambiance relaxing. Definitely recommend!
Ate there last night 3/12.
It had been at least 20 years since I was in the place. The decor and style changed drastically. The bar looked completely different. I definitely liked the way it looked. Was seated immediately. I didn't need a menu because I had already looked at
First time at Old Homestead and it won't be the last.
We're from Wyoming so have eaten many good steaks, but never any better than here. Henry's menu knowledge was impeccable, service was top notch, conversation was engaging and we were more friends than customers as we departed.
Where's the Beef? Old Homestead!!! :)
☆☆☆☆Omg! I'm a foody and appreciative of good food, service, and ambiance. Bing~bang, Old Homestead, covers all three, lol. The Prime Rib was a little well done but tasty. The broccoli rabbe was tough but garlicky flavorful. The spinach saut
The most proper drink you will have in the borgata! They
The most proper drink you will have in the borgata! They mix the most delicious drinks! Attention to detail is not missed in the wonderfully flavorful drinks I had the most delicious steak and added a lobster tail! Delicious The kids were with us
The service is great here, the food is also very well.
I love the shrimp cocktail. It's a huge piece of shrimp for a good price.
Located in the Borgata Casino ; where you can conveniently
Located in the Borgata Casino ; where you can conveniently self or valet park. A very large beautiful restaurant immaculately kept with wonderful menu. If you are looking for place to celebrate or have business meeting make this your place . Their si
Not our best Valentines Day dinner
My husband arranged a surprise trip to AC for Valentines Day which started with dinner at the Old Homestead. The food and service were beyond great but… we were seated at the absolute worst table in the place. To my right and within my reach was th
Absolutely incredible steak.
Even better service. Thank you for such a great dinner experience
I have eaten here quite a few times.
Usually very good. Had dinner there last night, sat pretty much right away, took about 10 minutes for someone to come over to the table. Waiter introduced himself, and helper. Took drink order, about 10 minutes later we got our drinks. Had to sto
My boyfriend and I came down for the night to see a show at
My boyfriend and I came down for the night to see a show at Caesars and were spending the night at Borgata. My boyfriend has eaten at the Old Homestead in manhattan before, loved it so I made reservations for dinner here. Our waiter, Michael was fant
Awesome service (sat at bar).
Veal Chop and Rack of Lamb outstanding - just perfect. Oysters eh at best; not really shelled well. Pieces of shell and ya had to dig at the meat to get it. Just what you would and should expect from Old Homestead. Like.
Old Homestead : Food and service was excellent
Food and service was excellent. Made reservation online which was very simple and efficient. Dinner was well worth the $$. Thursday in Jan still had a decent crowd.
Paul,you and your team are amazing!! thanks for a great
Paul,you and your team are amazing!! thanks for a great service! From Hudson Toyota team!
I REALLY miss Bobby Flays!
We have always had a good experience in the past coming to Old Homestead. Our last visit was a little disappointing as we had reservations well in advanced but had to wait over 30 minutes to be seated. Then we were seated in the hallway right next to
Dinner before Sienfield
This old reliable restaurant did not disappoint. The special veal chop was cooked to perfection. The broccoli rabe was excellent. Our servers Micheal and Gladys were wonderful. They made our experience so much better. It was a fabulous way to celeb
Awful experience
Awful experience my wife and I both got food poisoning and it is impossible to speak with anyone at the restaurant. Very disappointing
Not Good
Recently dined at Old Homestead for business and it was disappointing , especially since I have dined there before and always enjoyed it . The service was good and the drinks were good , the food was not , our porterhouse was overcooked and bland ,
Traditional Steakhouse Delivering What You Expect
The food was excellent and initially, our service was great. But after the food came, it was hard to get service or the attention we needed. For example, we asked for a sauce that never came. Also, their salads are massive and serve two people; we
Horrible experience
I have been coming here for years and last night was a complete disappointment from the host (Brian P) to the serving staff to the filets. We arrived at 8:25 for r 8:30 reservation. Wasn’t seated until around 8:50. Once seated in the “hall way
Nice dinner.
Dinned here after a show couple of Sunday’s ago. I had the chicken parm and have to say that this could be the best chicken parmigiana in AC and I have tried many at different restaurants. The chicken cooked very nicely, juicy and good flavor and
Made reservations (March16)at Borgata for my 60th birthday
Made reservations (March16)at Borgata for my 60th birthday and dinner at Old Homestead . Been kind of a tradition most years until the pandemic hit so was super excited to return . We arrived promptly at 8:55 for our 9:00pm reservation and wow what a
Here in Atlantic City this weekend celebrating my husband's
Here in Atlantic City this weekend celebrating my husband's 50th. We went to Old Homestead at the Borgata. The food was absolutely delicious. The rolls pictured are an onion. They do have rolls with walnuts but we passed on those being we do not like
One of the best steakhouses I have ever visited.
There were a lot of that ordered everything from steaks to salads. I have a hard time voting for what was best because it was all so good! The crab appetizer was perfect, the arugala salad with goat cheese was beyond, the cake portions were insane, a
Love this place love the food and love the decor of the
Love this place love the food and love the decor of the place.. . I eat here everytime I stay at the borgata, the waiters and buss people are top notch! I also go to the NYC location...
Pricey and ok tasting, I still enjoyed the service and food.
I really like their bread and butter. I ordered the burger and it was good but not worth $40.
Connect with users posting reservations for Old Homestead Steak House Atlantic City
AppointmentTrader is a community-driven platform where users can exchange their reservations or leverage their personal relationships with Old Homestead Steak House Atlantic City. Buyers can make informed decisions using automated seller ratings, which reflect past transactions and reliability.
Each posting on AppointmentTrader shows you which user submitted it and along with that provides a trackrecord of that user which indicates how much experience
the user has and how many percent of their transactions resulted in them issuing a refund.
If there is no user posting that fits your schedule, you can bid on your preferred time.
Let's say Peter has a great morning and decides to take his three friends to Old Homestead Steak House Atlantic City at 6 PM the same day.
He checks the restaurant's website and sees that no reservations are available. He then looks at the Old Homestead Steak House Atlantic City page on AppointmentTrader, but finds that there are no user postings either.
That's where the community-driven bid process comes in.
Peter can place a bid on AppointmentTrader, which serves as a reward for any community member who chooses to work on securing the reservation. AT then notifies experienced users who may be able to help.
Step-by-Step Process
1.) Setting a Reward (Bid)
* AppointmentTrader uses historical data to recommend a reasonable reward amount for securing a reservation - let's say $100.
* Peter really wants to go, so he increases the bid (or reward) to $200.
* At this stage, the reservation does not exist yet.
2.) A Community User Picks Up the Bid
* EternalAnt36, an experienced AT user, has a strong track record of successfully securing reservations and low refund requests, they receive a notification about Peter's $200 bid.
* EternalAnt36 picks up the bid, meaning they will now work on securing the reservation.
* Peter can now talk to EternalAnt36 for any questions Peter may have as EternalAnt36 user fills the bid.
3.) Finding the Reservation
* EternalAnt36 now uses their connections at Old Homestead Steak House Atlantic City to secure the table.
* If they successfully get the 6 PM table for four, Peter receives a confirmation that the reservation has been secured.
* If EternalAnt36 fails to secure the reservation, the bid is returned to the pool so another user can try.
4.) Payment & Protection
* Once the reservation is secured, EternalAnt36 receives the $200 reward which is credited to EternalAnt36's AT balance, where users manage their own funds and can withdraw via available payout options such as bank transfer, PayPal, or Zelle.
* Peter can now enjoy the dinner with his friends at Old Homestead Steak House Atlantic City!
* As with all transactions on AT, disputes and no-show fees are handled through the platform's community-driven resolution system. Users with a strong track record are incentivized to fulfill bids successfully, and community members can report issues to maintain trust in the marketplace.
