Save up to 30% at American Hotel Sag Harbor!
Have someone use their loyalty points to book your stay or buy a reservation from someone who can't make it to theirs.
If there is nothing that fits your schedule, you can bid on your preferred time.
We only list verified Reservations!
All listed Reservations are reviewed by our team before appearing in the calendar or being allowed to answer a bid you place. That's why AppointmentTrader comes with a included Money Back Guarantee for each transaction.
0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 |
American Hotel Sag Harbor Reviews from The Last Year
My visit is based off of a bar visit only! I have a book
My visit is based off of a bar visit only! I have a book about touring the Hamptons and and there when I have time I go through the book and pick out some stuff to check out that the book recommends. The American Hotel bar was one of the places to visit. I walked in and the atmosphere was quiet when I went in and spotted the bar pretty easily. I sat down and had one on one service from the bartender since I was the only one there. I don't drink alcohol anymore but recently I have been having non alcoholic beers here and there and the bartender had one in stock so he poured me a non alcoholic beer. It cost me $15 including leaving a decent size tip for a drink since I normally tip $1 a drink when I go out. It's a more swankier place so I expected a higher price. The bar seems to have a good selection for alcohol drinking people and if there were more people there it might have been a more fun atmosphere, for me it was more of a relaxing, take a few minutes to get myself together atmosphere which I appreciated. Maybe one day if I've got more money I'll spend the night as a guest in this hotel.
This is the place to be if you are a local or know how to
This is the place to be if you are a local or know how to be treated properly. Food is amazingly. Staff is superior hospitality level and the most important is the wine. lol. International list from A to Z and the most important list I've seen till today.
Favorite place to get a drink and relax.
Amazing decor. Recommend happy hour menu. Great martini.
This review is for the restaurant.
The food was utterly forgettable. Salad was overdressed, lobster was a bit tough, scallop potatoes were dreadfully bland and even salt could not save them. The service, however, was TERRIBLE. Server forgot to bring my husband's glass of wine. I wanted a vodka martini and asked what sort of vodkas they had and he obnoxiously responded asking which vodka I wanted so I asked for Chopin to which he subsequently responded, "We don't have that. What's next on your list (of vodka brands) ?" Overall an unpleasant and unrefined experience from start to finish.
Atmospheric and a delightful way to enjoy Sag Harbor
As a tourist to the US, we had been staying in Connecticut and decided to have a trip to Long Island and to stay in Sag Harbor. Travelling over by as many ferries as possible (along the North Fork, we passed many rows of grapes and wineries which was a great help (see later). Having settled on Sag Harbor, The American Hotel was an obvious choice (late November may not be an ideal place for a waterfront hotel) so it was with curiosity we ventured into Reception which was located behind a display cabinet of cigars and in a comfortable lounge atmosphere. This gave us a sense of what to expect and, having checked into our room, (a tad chilly until the heat kicked in - this was late November) we were able to relax and savour the atmosphere of the hotel. Dinner was in a delightfully atmospheric setting and very interesting as this was an 'all you can eat' lobster evening. The appetiser and dessert showed the culinary talent in the kitchen, but the industrial catering required to produce dozens of lobsters meant they sadly lacked flavour. The wine list was a tour de force. Every grape and region seemed to be covered, so we narrowed it down to North Fork, Long Island and chose a tasty white. Overall, we had a good time at a wonderfully atmospheric hotel and would happily stay again.
Charming restaurant.
Very good waiter, Dennis, who guided us well through the menu. I ordered the Caesar salad and flounder meunière. My husband ordered the Bay scallops which only are available a few weeks in the year. He is still talking about them. Our friends had the crab cake and Dover sole. Professional staff. Good drinks. Must go back !
Brought my little girl to this iconic restaurant in
Brought my little girl to this iconic restaurant in beautiful Sag Harbor. Retro elegance ambiance is a fact here. Service was impeccable. They didn't miss a beat. We didn't feel rushed even though we were only a two top. The wine Bible needed two people to carry to the table. Staff was helpful with recommendations. Went with my gut feeling for an 18 year old Burgundy and was very happy. Sweetbreads and paté to start. My daughter tried them both, enjoying the cherries with the paté but not so much the sweetbreads. The texture was what I know and expect: a soft creamy middle with a nice firmer texture on the outside. Maybe not so much for a 10 year old. She said she liked it but wouldn't order it. Though the paté she kept going in for more than her own salad. Like clockwork, my daughter orders the filet mignon for her entree (you don't want your son dating a salad entree girl, trust me). Cooked to perfection. I had the brace of quail veronique. Perfect amount of food. Tender, flavorful, aromatic, succulent, and a perfect pairing to my Burgundy. Banana's Fosters for my date and a sauternes for myself for dessert. Pictures to come
Very expensive, dessert dropped on my husband and we still
Very expensive, dessert dropped on my husband and we still had to pay. Hamburger came on English muffin bun. Would not recommend this place, go into NYC more to do and nicer atmosphere, and just as expensive, or maybe less.
Had a lovely dinner with family, excellent service by
Had a lovely dinner with family, excellent service by Dennis and his minions. From apps to dessert nothing to do but rave. Cannot say enough about the quality and superb cuisine. Fresh, delicious and prepared with an attention to detail. I highly recommend this as a true exceptional dining experience.
Hi hi! I was recently there for a lovely lunch and I must
Hi hi! I was recently there for a lovely lunch and I must say, the food was superb! I was, however, disappointed that the to-go routine involved a sloppy tinfoil situation. Owning my own food service business, and having worked in the restaurant business for 20+ years, I'm at a loss for why you are sending leftovers home in messy tinfoil balls. The caliber of service and food at your establishment is bar none, so it's strange that you'd choose to book-end that experience with the slovenly choice of messy tinfoil. Everything rolled into a ball of everything? Really? Gross. Clam-shell to-go containers cost close to nothing. Consider your customers. Thank you and love you!!
Top class service and outstanding food.
Wonderful dining experience and would recommend to anyone!
Sag Harbor's Best Hotels that are most frequently booked by customers of American Hotel Sag Harbor
Great Service - amazing dinner!!
Read about the site in NYT and bought a reservation at Mother Wolf in LA 2 days later. Worked great and the food was amazing!!!
Worked perfectly!
Got the reservation (that I couldn't get anywhere else) and was able to entertain a group of friends at the infamous Bern's Steakhouse.
Got into Nobu Malibu
Wonderful! My parents are visiting and we have wanted to go to Nobu Malibu for years. I tried getting a reservation myself but it was next to impossible. So glad I was able to buy a reservation on appointment trader for a decent price!
Very easy
Was very hesitant going into this experience but am glad to say that it worked out very well ! will definitely use appointment trader in the future
Fabulous Lunch
I was veeeeeerry skeptical that this would work, particularly at a restaurant as hard to get into as Nobu Malibu, and it was perfect! We had lunch outside on the patio and it was fabulous!
Great reviewer team
Just wanted to take a second to shout out the reviewer team. Even though they probably review hundreds of listings and bids a day, they still take the time to leave great comments and respond relatively quickly. Thanks!
Incredible
I got a reservation to Don Angie, which I've been trying to book for weeks! I am very happy with this service.
Best platform out there!
Super simple, easy, and fast to secure reservations for hard-to-get restaurants and locations!
This app is life changing
This app has opened my world up to so many wonderful new experiences I would never have the chance to have without access to this awesome app! 10/10!
Worked perfectly
Was a little nervous at first but was pleased to see that the booking went through flawlessly.
Highly recommended.
Success on Short Notice
Was able to snag an indoor table at Don Angie through an absolutely seamless worry-free process.
Worked perfectly, thank you!
This is a crazy holiday season in NYC and I was very pleasantly surprised to see that AppointmentTrader works! Will be using again!
Worked flawlessly!
Worked so well! I was a bit nervous, but everything went very smoothly. purchased the reservation, and got into the restaurant seamlessly.
Love this app!
So glad I came across this app :)
Quick table in Miami
I didn’t have my hopes high as it was a party of 4. In 24 hours I had a carbone reservation available! I was very happy as my family really wanted to come here
Prime time, great meal
So easy and had a prime time which I can never seem to get on normal res apps. So worth it
Got impossible NYC res
instead of waiting weeks I got my 4 charles reservation instantly
Worked perfectly to get into Carbone. So delighted
perfect
Worked well, got me into a restaurant with no availability
I was skeptical, and I still don't really know how they managed to find this hard-to-find reservation, but it was a win-win from my point of view, and I'll use this service again.
Last minute reservation for Delilah Las Vegas
Got a last minute reservation, dinner for 2 at Delilah Las Vegas: super impressed! The process was simple, transaction seamless. We had an amazing time! Couldn’t be happier! 😍
It works!
Ok at this point I've attended a reservation purchased on AT by a friend and sold a reservation personally. Both worked pretty smoothly, nothing sketchy about it. A few areas for improvement including a way to more directly communicate between buyers and sellers, but the app always seems to be in development. AT customer support is really(!) responsive and helpful too if you have questions!
Money transfer
As a seller, I like the fact i have the ability now to transfer money out of my AT account and into a bank account. Makes getting the money much easier then the process before.
Love this app
Got to go to places otherwise unreachable
Easy Access
Very easy to get into one of the hardest restaurants to reserve in New York.
Tune into NBC News - Top Story Tonight 7:40p ET
Let’s go. Get more people placing bids!
I will give you 50% of ALL of my PROFITS if you teach me how to make profits?
LOL. Thank you The New Yorker.
Appointment
Transferring reservations is not supported in AT. Why not just use the name in the AT screenshot?
Buyers interested in Bern's Steakhouse: PLEASE READ
Same goes for 4 Charles and I Sodi
Prepaid Reservation Fee
Agreed. Ultimately not addressing this month after month is clearly resulting in a drop in certain venue’s rankings & sales.
Congrats on 3 mil
🍾🍾🍾🍾🍾🍾🧨🧨🧨 now on to 30 mill!
Need to cancel a bid, not getting a response… how do I do it?
Click on "Take off the Market Option" in your portfolio
Working on your bid?
Your bid has been “matched” with a reservation. From the time a reservation has been located, the seller of the reservation must connect with moderator to give transfer information for reservation. If the seller;however, does NOT respond to reservation transfer, then your bid is reprocessed and returns to the first step, which is connecting your request to a reservation.
Process after bid is accepted.
Hey @EvocativeFold67, welcome to appointmenttrader! Once the reservation is in your portfolio, you definitely own the timeslot, the review team would not have approved the trade if the reservation wasn't confirmed - so you are going :-) Judging from your post you bid today and are going tomorrow - don't worry as long as you initiated the name transfer, you are good - the transfer service has to work with the opening hours of the reservation team of the respective venue. You will likely see the transfer confirmation a couple hours before your reservation time.
Where do the Reservations on AppointmentTrader come from?
Mostly from people who don't need their reservations or appointments any longer. AT has no relationship with places listed and acts as a platform connecting buyers and sellers making sure that listed reservations are real and that privacy is not compromised when transacting.
What happens if my bid expires unanswered?
Hey @FluffyStar64, thanks for the question! When you place your bid the amount gets transferred in a deposit account, the second you either cancel your bid or a few minutes after the bid expires the funds are moved back into your main account from where you can refund it to your payment method or use for other transactions.
American Hotel Sag Harbor User Reviews & Question Forums
🤮 | 🤢 | 😒 | 🙂 | 😍 |
American Hotel Sag Harbor Yelp Reviews |
Latest Reviews On Yelp
By 👻 @Diana B. (03/07/2024 3:00 am)
American Hotel Sag Harbor Tripadvisor Reviews |
Latest Reviews On Tripadvisor
By 👻 @AntonyHurden (02/01/2024 3:00 am)
AppointmentTrader Platform Reviews |
Reviews from real people using AT!
By 👻 @GainfulEdge65 (03/19/2024 2:48 am)
AppointmentTrader FAQ |
Questions and Answers around the platform.
By ✔ @DeliciousMatch37 (06/08/2024 1:25 pm)